CHEST Guidelines-Rebuttal-From-Dr-Walz

Rebuttal-From-Dr-Walz_chest

Pdf Summary

The document is a discussion on airway management in critically ill patients, focusing particularly on the complexities and complications associated with endotracheal intubation in intensive care units (ICUs). Dr. Matthias Walz and Dr. Doerschug deliver rebuttals on the best practices for managing difficult airways. Dr. Walz emphasizes the importance of involving anesthesiologists in emergency endotracheal intubations (EEIs), arguing that their expertise is crucial, especially given the difficulties posed by the nuances of critical care airways. He suggests that a team approach, which transcends medical specialties, could help reduce complications. Dr. Walz stresses that structured environments and team collaboration, rather than individual expertise, should be the standard.<br /><br />Dr. Doerschug agrees on several issues, including the unpredictability of airway difficulties, the importance of viewing all airways as potentially difficult, and the necessity for those performing intubations to be skilled in various techniques. However, he contests that pulmonologists, through greater involvement and experience in intubations, can minimize severe complications. He argues that increasing the frequency of intubations performed by pulmonary intensivists could help optimize ICU intubation outcomes. Dr. Doerschug highlights the importance of alternative techniques like videolaryngoscopes and extraglottic airways, which have high success rates in emergency intubations, even for non-anesthesiologists.<br /><br />Both authors concur that collaboration between anesthesiologists and pulmonary specialists is vital. They warn against adversarial relations between specialties, advocating for a more systematic and cooperative approach to airway management in the ICU to limit complications and improve patient outcomes. They call for future structured programs and randomized trials to enhance the safety and effectiveness of airway management in critically ill patients.

Keywords

airway management

critically ill patients

endotracheal intubation

ICU

anesthesiologists

pulmonologists

team collaboration

videolaryngoscopes

extraglottic airways

patient outcomes