CHEST Guidelines-Response_chest

Response_chest_31 (1)
Pdf Summary
This document is a correspondence regarding a commentary published in "Chest" magazine, titled "Chicken Soup in the Time of COVID." The authors respond to a letter from Drs. Brown and Miller and Ms. Miller, expanding on their discussion about the cultural and health-related aspects of chicken soup, traditionally associated with comfort and healing.<br /><br />The correspondence appreciates the etymological insight into the term “Bubbie,” a Yiddish word for grandmother, symbolizing a social role that transcends cultural boundaries. The conversation touches on the universal significance of grandmothers, highlighting their role in imparting values such as empathy, fairness, and honesty, often conveyed through storytelling and life experiences. These values equip families to navigate challenges, like pandemics and social injustice.<br /><br />The authors draw a parallel between medical science and traditional practices like chicken soup making. They emphasize that while science relies on metrics and rigorous methods, tradition (as seen in chicken soup recipes) often involves empiricism and social feedback. They reference the historical belief in the benefits of chicken soup, supported by a study showing it inhibits neutrophil chemotaxis in vitro.<br /><br />Additionally, the correspondence cites significant developments in COVID-19 treatment. The emergency use authorization for hydroxychloroquine was revoked, while remdesivir has shown effectiveness, and dexamethasone's value is under review. These instances highlight the importance of scientifically grounded decisions.<br /><br />The authors conclude that while tastes may vary regarding chicken soup ingredients, like dill, medical decisions should be rooted in evidence. They advocate for making choices that align with scientific integrity and values that would make our grandmothers proud, emphasizing a blend of tradition and science in our actions.
Keywords
Chicken Soup
COVID-19
Cultural Aspects
Healing Traditions
Grandmothers
Medical Science
Hydroxychloroquine
Remdesivir
Dexamethasone
Scientific Integrity